A friend of mine passed along this book review that turned viral. Basically, the blogger Big Al gave the book ‘The Greek Seaman’ a mediocre rating, saying it had an interesting story but the grammatical errors could be distracting. The writer, Jacqueline Howett, being a classy professional, started harassing the reviewer in the comments section, saying he didn’t know what he was talking about and that her writing is perfect. As more and more readers took Big Al’s side, Ms. Howett continued to insult the blogger and prove his point – her comments were poorly written. She eventually gave up on “coherent” arguments and started using expletives instead. Big Al’s blog Books and Pals may seem unimportant but apparently professionals in the publishing world follow Big Al (if they didn’t before, they probably do now since the review went viral) and I’m sure Ms. Howett’s writing career may be impossible to salvage.
The lessons we can learn from this? 1. You can’t expect everyone to love your work. 2. Don’t ever respond to a bad review, especially not publicly. 3. Keep good friends around you who’ll let you know when you’re making an ass of yourself so you’ll know to shut up before things get worse.
Check out the train wreck for yourselves.
